Why Public Transit Sucks in the United States: Four Videos Tell the Story


Many other phrases may just describe the state of public transportation in America these days. In fresh a long time, increasingly of a consensus turns out to have settled round one phrase in explicit: that it “sucks.” Given its “antiquated generation, protection considerations, crumbling infrastructure,” and steadily “nonexistence,” says the narrator of the video above, “it’s no longer arduous to argue that the U.S. public transportation community shouldn’t be just right.” That narrator, Sam Denby, is the writer of Wendover Productions, a Youtube channel all about geography, generation, economics, and the infrastructure the place all 3 intersect. He believes no longer best that America’s public transit sucks, however that the nation’s “loss of cast public transportation nearly defines American tradition.”

This would make a definite sense in a deficient, small, suffering nation — however no longer in the United States of America, described no longer way back via Anne Applebaum in the Atlantic as “familiar with considering of itself as the highest, most productive, and maximum technologically complicated society in the global.”

As somebody making their first discuss with will enjoy, America’s still-formidable wealth and tool doesn’t sq. with the enjoy on the flooring, or certainly beneath it: whether or not via subway, bus, or streetcar, the process of navigating maximum U.S. towns is characterised via inconvenience, discomfort, or even impossibility. This in a rustic whose public transportation as soon as truly used to be the envy of the global: at the flip of the 20th century, its towns boasted 11,000 miles of streetcar monitor on my own.

In the mid-2010s, via Denby’s reckoning, “the blended mileage of each tram, subway, mild rail, and commuter rail machine” added up best to five,416. What came about in the hundred or so years between? He cites amongst different components the manufacturing of the first extensively reasonably priced vehicles in the 1920s, and later that of buses, with their decrease working prices than streetcars — however as recurrently operated these days, their lower-quality transit enjoy as neatly. (Resentment about this large-scale alternative of city streetcar programs runs deep sufficient to make some imagine it a conspiracy.) The U.S. “grew up as the automotive grew up, so its towns had been constructed for automobiles,” particularly in its extra lately settled west. Indirect subsides reduced the value of gasoline, and from the 1950s the constructing of the Interstate Highway System made it simple, a minimum of for at time, to shuttle between town and suburb.

As identified in the Vox movies “Why American Public Transit Is So Bad” and “How Highways Wrecked American Cities,” those huge roads ran no longer round or beneath towns (as they do in a lot of Europe and Asia) however instantly via their facilities, a part of a bigger strategy of “city renewal” that satirically destroyed somewhat a couple of of what dense city neighborhoods the U.S. had. More than part a century of highway-building, suburbanization, and strict zoning later, maximum Americans to find themselves not able to get the place they wish to cross with out purchasing a automotive and riding themselves. The state of affairs is even worse for the ones touring between towns, as tested above in Wendover Productions’ “Why Trains Suck in America.” As an American, I take a definite pleasure in listening to those questions addressed — however I take a fair larger one in being an American dwelling out of the country.

Related Content:

A Subway Ride Through New York City: Watch Vintage Footage from 1905

Designer Massimo Vignelli Revisits and Defends His Iconic 1972 New York City Subway Map

Archive of 5,000 Images Document the History of San Francisco and the Vehicles That Put It in Motion

Trips on the World’s Oldest Electric Suspension Railway in 1902 & 1917 Show How a City Changes Over a Century

A Brief History of the Great American Road Trip

Based in Seoul, Colin Marshall writes and proclaims on towns, language, and tradition. His tasks come with the Substack publication Books on Cities, the ebook The Stateless City: a Walk via 21st-Century Los Angeles and the video collection The City in Cinema. Follow him on Twitter at @colinmarshall or on Facebook.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here